Believe the Hype: ‘You Can See Everything’ Is Worth Seeing and Really Is Everything

Documentaries, by their very nature, promise the truth. Blend that with a little reality TV and the tantalising prospect of unravelling a crime, and you've got a viewing proposition that's pretty hard to resist.
At this point, you could argue that the case of Elizabeth Holmes is open and shut. Once hailed as Silicon Valley's ultimate tech heroine, Holmes built her blood-testing company, Theranos, into a business valued at a staggering US$9 billion, convincing investors she'd developed revolutionary technology capable of running hundreds of medical tests from just a few drops of blood. The problem? It didn't work as promised. Yet Holmes managed to raise more than US$700 million from investors, while patients were subjected to unreliable blood tests, some receiving dangerously inaccurate results. It was one of the most spectacular corporate frauds in recent history.
On 3 January 2022, Holmes was convicted of four counts of fraud and conspiracy against investors and, on 18 November that year, sentenced to 11 years and three months in prison. Alongside her former business partner and boyfriend, Sunny Balwani, she was ordered to repay a staggering US$452 million to defrauded investors. She began serving her sentence on 30 May 2023.
So, if she's guilty, what's the documentary really about, then?
For starters, there's the rather curious question of why Holmes and her husband, Billy Evans, would invite filmmaker Nathan Fielder, best known for his unconventional blend of comedy, reality and psychological experimentation, and co-director Lance Oppenheim into their rental home just a month before she was due to enter prison. One would assume their remaining time together would be precious, particularly with two very young children.
Then there's the psychology behind Holmes' steadfast insistence that she's innocent. Have we all missed some pivotal piece of evidence that could cast her conviction in an entirely different light? Is this her opportunity to make her case, this time in the court of public opinion?
Or maybe, just maybe, we simply want to know what makes the brilliant mind of the so-called 'female Steve Jobs' tick. Who the heck is Elizabeth Holmes, anyway? The footage and interviews we've seen over the years reveal a reserved, if not banal, woman who gives remarkably little away. Even those enormous eyes, which seem to promise a window into her soul, reveal absolutely nothing. She's something of a blinking, blank canvas.
Against this backdrop, the film aptly opens with a tight shot of Evans explaining that he wants to show the world who his wife really is, why he loves her and, presumably, why the rest of us have got her so terribly wrong. It's a bold opening gambit that sets the stage for what initially appears to be a carefully orchestrated exercise in image rehabilitation. But as the cameras roll, the couple's attempts to control the narrative become a fascinating part of the story itself.
And herein lies the beauty of this outstanding film.

Filmaker Nathan Fielder
Through an extraordinarily clever combination of filmmaking, psychological observation and what can only be described as strategic discomfort, Fielder allows Holmes and Evans to reveal far more than they perhaps intended.
The old adages about giving someone enough rope to hang themselves and never bullshitting a bullshitter come to mind. Fielder, himself a master of blurring fiction with reality, appears to play Holmes and Evans at their own game, leaving the viewer feeling rather like someone emerging from a haunted mansion. You're not entirely sure what you've just witnessed or, perhaps more unsettlingly, who's been playing whom, and there's something rather frightening about that.
Cinematically, Fielder sets the tone from the get-go, filming tighter and closer than almost anything I've seen before, refreshingly veering away from conventional documentary territory and into something resembling a psychological thriller. The camera captures every wrinkle and pore, every dilation of the pupils, nervous twitch, fleeting expression and subtle emotional inflection that might otherwise go unnoticed. Combined with the deliberately slow pace, the effect is almost forensic. You're not simply watching Holmes and Evans; you're studying them through a microscope, like a science experiment, searching for something, anything, that might give the game away.
Fielder's narration is equally sharp, direct and strategically timed, with his questioning leaving little room for manoeuvre. For anyone who's ever dealt with a narcissist and subsequently disappeared down the rabbit hole of psychology trying to make sense of it all, it's a joy to behold.
At times, it's almost comical watching Holmes respond with tears but no tissue (because apparently she's perfectly comfortable letting her eyes and nose run freely until Fielder simply can't take it anymore and goes hunting for a Kleenex in her own home). Then there's her trademark blank expression, dead eyes and that rather unsettling scary-clown grin, sometimes, disconcertingly, all three at once.
Evans, meanwhile, has perfected his own exit-stage-left routine, conveniently calling "cut" whenever the questions get a little too close for comfort, despite the rather inconvenient fact that he isn't the film's director.
And therein lies the brilliance of Fielder's approach. He doesn't need to accuse, confront or even raise his voice, least of all an eyebrow. He simply asks the questions, sits with the uncomfortable silence and lets his subjects do the rest.
Things get particularly interesting when Fielder introduces Amanda Seyfried, who famously portrayed Holmes in the award-winning television miniseries The Dropout. Initially brought in to offer her take on who the real Elizabeth Holmes might be, Seyfried soon finds herself woven into the documentary itself, slipping back into character to recreate conversations and events after Holmes is imprisoned and can no longer be filmed directly.
It's a deliciously bizarre twist that leaves your mind scrambling to distinguish fact from fiction, reality from performance and art from life. Just when you think you've worked out what you're watching, the lines blur all over again. Is it art imitating life, life imitating art, or have we reached the point where even the people involved can no longer tell the difference?
But what at first blush appears to be another entertaining filmmaking trick underscores something far more unsettling. Seyfried doesn't really know who Elizabeth Holmes is. Neither does Fielder, the viewer or, perhaps most intriguingly, Holmes herself.
And it's this realisation that circles spectacularly back to the film's opening premise, effectively turning the entire exercise on its head. What began as an attempt to uncover 'the real Elizabeth Holmes' becomes a question of whether there's an authentic person at all beneath the carefully constructed persona.

As the film progresses, an increasingly fascinating tug-of-war develops between the filmmaker and the couple.
Fielder begins joining the dots, probing inconsistencies and quietly challenging the version of events being presented to him. Evans, meanwhile, appears determined to retain control of the very production he willingly invited into his own home.
The resulting power struggle takes on a life of its own, with the situation seemingly free-falling out of control almost as spectacularly as Holmes’ meteoric rise and fall.
And perhaps that’s the greatest irony of all. Holmes and Evans may have invited Fielder into their home believing they could dictate how their story would be told, only to find themselves being quietly outmaneuvered.
Or were they?
Who's to say they didn't manage to manipulate Fielder, too? After all, even the most astute observer isn't immune to seeing what they want to see.
I left the theatre with my daughters, and what followed was another three hours of debating our observations, interpretations and psychological diagnoses as we tried to make sense of what we'd just watched. And somewhere in the middle of all that discussion, we arrived at what I think is the film's most fascinating revelation.
Everyone sees what they want to see.
Our interpretations are shaped by our own experiences, biases, expectations and, perhaps most importantly, motivations, which brings us rather neatly back to Elizabeth Holmes and that unnerving air of impenetrability she seems to possess.
Because perhaps that was her greatest trick all along, and the very thing that lured us into the theatre in the first place. What you see is what you get. By giving people so little of herself, she allowed others to project whatever they wanted onto her, whether that was the visionary, the genius, the misunderstood entrepreneur or the victim.
And in doing so, she came breathtakingly close to pulling off one of the most audacious corporate frauds in modern history. Not simply because she convinced people to believe in her, but because she understood something fundamental about human nature.
Sometimes, people are all too willing to deceive themselves.



Comments